On Thursday morning, Space X CEO Elon Musk tweeted that he had received “verbal govt approval” to build an underground “hyperloop” that would connect New York City to Washington, only taking commuters a mere 29 minutes to travel just under 230 miles. The tweet drummed up considerable excitement, but left many wondering: who exactly gave this apparent government approval?

In a later tweet Musk clarified that the verbal approval came from the “federal level” but failed to identify who exactly.

The mystery served only to further build the hype around the already enticing story.

 

Yet, not everyone is excited by Musk’s announcement. In fact, it seems many were blindsided by it, including most New York politicians who apparently were unaware of Musk’s plans.

 

The MTA was similarly in the dark.

 

Ben Sarle, Deputy press secretary for the mayor's office was equally perplexed, stating, “Nobody in City Hall, or any of our city agencies, has heard from Mr. Musk or any representatives of his company.”

Watch the hyperloop complete its first successful test ride:

Some, such as Preet Bharara, suggested that Elon should use his genius to help solve the escalating subway crisis.

 

 

Others were simply not happy with the plan, claiming it prioritizes unrealistic fantasies over real infrastructure plans such as the Gateway Program, which is still waiting to receive federal funding.

Richard Barone, Vice President for Transportation Programs at the Regional Plan Association stated that “Hyperloop needs to be weighed next to more conventional and proven technologies like high speed rail, which would incrementally build off of our legacy investments, including existing rights-of-way and stations.”

Reporter Andrew Hawkins of the Verge was equally critical of the plan in a series of tweets where he suggested that the tunnel planned by the Gateway Program, which is only about 9,000 feet, should be prioritized over the 226 mile Hyperloop.

Despite its alleged “approval” Musk and the Hyperloop still have a long way to go to materialize this plan and convince citizens of its worth.